Have you ever noticed how good it feels to win?
Not in a big, flashy, life-changing way—but in a quiet, everyday kind of way.
You check something off your list.
You follow through on something you said you’d do.
You keep a promise to yourself.
It feels really good.
Now let me ask you this…
Why is it that when it comes to fitness, so many of us set ourselves up to lose?
The Fitness Trap So Many Women Fall Into
Somewhere along the way, we were taught that “consistency” in fitness looks like:
- 1 hour workouts
- 5 days a week
- Pushing hard every time
- Sweaty, exhausted, all-out effort
And if you’re not doing that?
You’re not trying hard enough.
You’re not committed enough.
You’re not doing it “right.”
That messaging is everywhere—and it’s convincing.
But here’s the problem:
That version of consistency doesn’t fit into real life for most women.
And it’s especially unrealistic during perimenopause.
Why Exercise Feels Harder to Stick With in Perimenopause
If you’ve ever thought…
“Why can’t I stay consistent like I used to?”
“Why does everything feel harder now?”
You’re not imagining it—and you’re definitely not failing.
Perimenopause brings real, physiological changes that directly impact your ability to stick with a traditional fitness routine.
Things like:
- Fluctuating hormones that affect energy, mood, and motivation
- Increased sensitivity to stress, making intense workouts harder to recover from
- Sleep disruptions, which reduce energy and increase fatigue
- Joint pain or stiffness, especially if you’re already dealing with old injuries or chronic conditions
- Longer recovery times, meaning you can’t just “push through” like you may have in your 20s or 30s
These changes aren’t just in your head—they’re well documented. Cleveland Clinic outlines how hormonal shifts during perimenopause can affect sleep, energy, and overall physical resilience, all of which play a role in how consistent you’re able to be with exercise:
👉 https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/21608-perimenopause
On top of that, you’re likely navigating a full life—work, family, responsibilities, maybe even caring for others.
That “1 hour, 5 days a week, go hard every time” model?
It doesn’t account for any of this.
And when your plan doesn’t match your reality, it’s not a motivation problem…
👉 It’s a strategy problem.
What If You Created a Game You Could Win?
This is something I say to my clients all the time:
Create a game you can win.
Because when you win?
You feel good.
And when you feel good, you’re more likely to keep going.
This is where the idea of a minimum baseline comes in.
What Is a Minimum Baseline?
Your minimum baseline is the lowest level of effort that still counts as a win.
Not your best day.
Not your ideal routine.
Not what you used to be able to do.
But what you can realistically do on a regular basis, with the time, energy, and capacity you actually have right now.
It should feel almost… too easy.
Like:
- “I can definitely do that.”
- “Even on a busy day, I could manage this.”
- “Even if I’m tired, I could still follow through.”
That’s the point.
Because consistency isn’t built on your best days.
It’s built on your most average ones.
Let’s Look at the Math (And What It Really Means)
Let’s compare two approaches.
Approach A: The “All In” Plan
- 1 hour per workout
- 5 days per week
- Total: 5 hours/week
Let’s say you keep that up for 2 months before life gets busy or your body pushes back:
👉 5 hours × 8 weeks = 40 hours total
Approach B: The Minimum Baseline
- 20 minutes per workout
- 3 days per week
- Total: 1 hour/week
And this time, you stick with it for a full year:
👉 1 hour × 52 weeks = 52 hours total
At first glance, those numbers might not look wildly different.
But here’s what is different:
Approach A (All In) often leads to:
- Burnout (mental and physical)
- Increased risk of injury
- Flare-ups of chronic pain
- Elevated cortisol levels from constant high intensity
- Poor recovery and lingering fatigue
- Disrupted sleep
- The all-or-nothing cycle (“I fell off, so why bother?”)
Which usually results in… stopping altogether.
Approach B (Minimum Baseline) creates:
- Steady, repeatable movement week after week
- Better recovery between sessions
- Lower overall stress on your system
- More stable energy levels
- Increased confidence and motivation
- Habits that actually stick
And most importantly:
👉 You stay in the game long enough to see real results.
So the question isn’t just:
“How many hours are you putting in?”
It’s:
“How long can you keep going?”
Because fitness results don’t come from what you do for 8 intense weeks.
They come from what you can sustain for months—and years.
Why Minimum Baseline Works
When your goal is achievable, a few important things happen:
- You follow through more often
- You build trust with yourself
- You reduce the all-or-nothing cycle
- You create momentum
- You stay consistent long enough to actually see results
And here’s the kicker:
You can always do more on the days you have the capacity.
But your baseline is your safety net—the thing that keeps you in the game when life gets hard.
Research supports this, too. Chronic stress—whether from life or consistently pushing your body too hard in workouts—can keep cortisol elevated, which impacts energy, sleep, and recovery over time. Harvard Health Publishing explains this really clearly in their article on the stress response:
👉 https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/understanding-the-stress-response
This Isn’t About Doing the Bare Minimum
Let’s be clear—this isn’t about settling.
It’s about being strategic.
It’s about recognizing that the most effective plan isn’t the one that looks the most intense…
It’s the one you can actually stick with.
Tips: How to Set Your Own Minimum Baseline
If you want to try this approach, here’s how to start:
1. Be honest about your real life
Not your ideal schedule—your actual one.
How much time and energy do you realistically have most days?
2. Lower the bar (yes, really)
If your plan feels a little too easy… you’re probably doing it right.
Think:
- 15–20 minutes
- 2–3 times per week
3. Define what counts as a “win”
Be specific.
Instead of “work out more,” try:
- “Complete 2 strength workouts this week”
- “Move my body for 15 minutes”
4. Keep it flexible
Your baseline is your minimum, not your limit.
If you feel good, you can always do more.
But you don’t have to.
5. Track your wins
This matters more than you think.
Every time you meet your baseline, you reinforce:
👉 “I’m someone who follows through.”
6. Give it time
The magic isn’t in one week.
It’s in what happens when you keep going for months.
The Bottom Line
You don’t need to work harder.
You need a plan that works with your life—not against it.
Because the real goal isn’t to have a perfect week…
It’s to build something you can keep coming back to.
Again and again.
You Don’t Have to Figure This Out Alone
If you’re reading this and thinking, “This is exactly what I need—but I don’t know how to put it into practice…”
You’re not alone.
Knowing what makes sense is one thing.
Actually building a routine that fits your body, your energy, and your life? That’s a whole different layer.
That’s exactly the kind of support I offer.
Inside my coaching and programs, we focus on helping you:
- Build strength in a way that feels doable (not overwhelming)
- Work with your body instead of pushing against it
- Create a minimum baseline that actually fits your real life
- Stay consistent without burning out or starting over (again)
Because you deserve a version of fitness that feels supportive—not stressful.
If that sounds like what you’ve been missing, I’d love to help.
Radiant Vitality – Kim Hagle
Body Positive Personal Trainer for Women Over 40. Located in Goderich, ON and serving clients online throughout North America
Check Out Our Latest Posts
-
What Is a Non-Scale Victory and Are They Accurate?
What is a non-scale victory, and are NSVs helping or hurting your motivation? Discover a weight-neutral approach to tracking real fitness progress.
-
How To Find The Motivation To Workout: 7 Ways To Finally Stay Consistent With Exercise
If you’ve been trying to figure out how to find the motivation to workout, you’re not alone; and you’re not broken. In my 15 years as a body-positive personal trainer, lack of motivation is the single most common reason people struggle to start or stay consistent with exercise. But here’s what most fitness advice gets…
-
Is Strength Training Safe If You Have Chronic Pain?
Wondering if strength training with chronic pain is actually safe? The short answer is yes — when it’s approached in a way that works with your body instead of against it. In this article, you’ll learn how to start strength training safely when living with chronic pain, fibromyalgia, fatigue, or mobility limitations. We’ll cover beginner-friendly…
0 Comments