What to Look for in a Personal Trainer as a Fitness Misfit

by | Nov 20, 2026

What to look for in a personal trainer is a harder question than it should be, especially if you’ve ever felt like fitness wasn’t made for you. This guide is for the fitness misfit who wants to move more, feel stronger, and not get hurt doing it. We’ll walk through credentials, interview questions, and what a good trainer actually feels like.

Here’s the problem. Personal trainers are a dime a dozen. A Google or Instagram search will land you what feels like 1,000 options, and so many of them boast drastic transformations, look like bodybuilders, or want to sell you their supplement “stack” to get the best results.

Becoming a personal trainer can also be surprisingly simple. In Canada, no law sets a minimum standard, and some certifications take as little as a weekend. So how do you filter through the before-and-afters and choose someone who’s actually going to work well for you and your needs?

I’m Kim, a body positive personal trainer, non-diet health coach, and body image coach. I’m also a fitness misfit myself. I was the kid picked last for teams, I live with chronic illness and pain, and I’ve worked my way through my own disordered relationship with exercise. I wrote this the way I’d want someone to explain it to me.


What to Look for in a Personal Trainer: Start by Getting Clear on Your Goals

Before you compare a single trainer, get clear on what you want from one. Ask yourself:

  • What do I want to be able to do? (Carry the groceries, play with the grandkids, get up off the floor, hike without worrying.)
  • Do I have injuries, pain, or health concerns a trainer needs to work around?
  • Do I want to train in person, online, or a mix of both?
  • What would make me feel safe and welcome in a session?

Jot down your answers. They’re your best filter for everything below.

Start with the basics

Because the industry is so loosely regulated, a few boxes are worth ticking with any trainer: a recognized certification from an organization you can look up, current CPR and first aid, and liability insurance. These are table stakes, so ask. A good trainer won’t be offended.

Match the trainer to your goal

If you want to bodybuild, compete in a fitness competition, or run a marathon, look for a trainer with the education and experience to train you for that specific goal. Ask who they’ve trained for it and how. A trainer who’s great at one kind of training isn’t automatically the right fit for another.

But What If You Feel Like a Misfit?

Maybe none of that sounds like you. You’re not training for a stage or a start line. You just want to move more and not get hurt while you do it. Maybe you’re a beginner, living with pain, in a larger body, or you’ve been burned by a gym or a trainer before.

You don’t need to “get in shape” first, either. The right trainer meets you exactly where you are. Read more here: Do You Need to Get in Shape Before Hiring a Personal Trainer?

What you need is someone who understands how real bodies move in real life. That’s where functional fitness comes in.

What Is Functional Fitness, and Why Does It Matter?

Functional fitness is training that builds the strength, stamina, and mobility you use in everyday life. Instead of isolating one muscle at a time, you practice movements that look like your actual day: squatting down and standing back up, lifting, carrying, pushing, pulling, twisting, and balancing.

Why choose a trainer who specializes in it? Because the goals line up with what most fitness misfits actually want. Getting off the floor without thinking about it. Climbing the stairs. Carrying all the bags in one trip. Feeling steady on a hike.

In a session, it might look like squatting to a chair, a hip hinge with a band or dumbbell (the same movement you use to pick a laundry basket off the floor), a carry, a push or a pull, and some balance work. Every movement gets adjusted to your body, your pain levels, and your day. And you measure progress by what gets easier in your life, not by a number on a scale.

Why Consider a Body Positive Personal Trainer

Functional fitness tells you what to train. A body positive approach shapes how you’re treated while you train. The two complement each other: functional fitness measures success by what your body can do, and body positive training makes sure no one is judging how it looks while it does it.

In practice, that looks like:

  • No weigh-ins and no body measurements
  • Modifications offered as standard practice, not as a favor you have to ask for
  • Programming built around your pain, injuries, energy, and real life
  • Language that never treats your body as a problem
  • Rest and scaling back treated as valid choices

All bodies are good bodies, and you work out to feel better, not to look different. If a trainer can’t get behind that, keep looking.

How to Find a Body Positive Personal Trainer: Extra Credentials and Questions to Ask

Once the basics are covered, here’s what separates a trainer who’s merely qualified from one who’s right for you.

Certifications to look for

Two additional credentials are worth looking for:

I hold both, and they shape how I coach every client.

Interview questions to ask a trainer

Most good trainers offer a free chat before you commit. Use it to ask:

  • What certifications do you hold, and what experience do you have with clients like me?
  • How do you modify exercises for injuries or chronic pain?
  • How do you measure progress without the scale?
  • What happens if I need to take a break or do less?
  • Do you talk about food or weight? Can we leave that out?

Listen for specific answers and zero defensiveness. If a question gets a sigh or a sales pitch, that’s your answer.

What a good first consultation feels like

A good trainer asks about your life, your sleep, your stress, and your injuries, not just your “goal weight.” You should leave feeling heard, not sized up. They explain the plan in plain language and make it clear you can go slower, change course, or say no.

Red flags

Before-and-after marketing, mandatory weigh-ins, “no excuses” talk, pushing supplements or diet plans, and treating rest as failure are all signs to walk away. I covered these in depth in Body Positivity in Fitness: What It Really Means. Read more if you want the full list.

Finding an Online Personal Trainer for Women Over 40

Online or in person? Both can work, and the right answer depends on you.

In-person training gives you hands-on cueing and access to equipment, but it also means travel, a set schedule, and a space that may or may not feel comfortable. Online training lets you work out at home, on your schedule, with a specialist who might live hundreds of kilometres away. The trade-off is that your trainer can’t adjust you by hand, so ask how they’ll check your form (video reviews are common) and how you’ll stay in touch between sessions.

I coach clients online across North America, so I’m biased, but the principle holds wherever you train: choose the setup where you feel most capable and least self-conscious.

Want to try my approach before committing to anything? Strong with Bands is a free 30-minute class that gives you a taste of movement made for your body.



What a Personal Trainer Costs: Is $300 a Month a Lot?

It’s a fair question. One Canadian roundup puts one-on-one sessions at roughly $60 to $150 and monthly packages at $300 to $800 or more, depending on your city, the trainer’s experience, and the format. So $300 a month isn’t unusual.

The better question is what you’re getting for it. Ask yourself:

  • Is the program built for me, or is it a template?
  • Can I reach my trainer between sessions?
  • Will they adjust when I’m in pain or having a hard week?
  • Will I leave sessions feeling capable?

A cheaper plan from someone who doesn’t understand your body isn’t a bargain if it gets you hurt or makes you quit. For reference, the Virtual tier of my personal training program, Movement Made for You is $275 a month, with custom programming for fitness misfits, injuries, and chronic pain.

Find a Trainer Who Gets You

You now know what to look for: the basics, a goal that fits, functional training, and a body positive approach that treats you like a person instead of a project. Movement Made for You is custom personal training built around your body, your pain points, and your pace, whether you train virtually or in real time. You apply, we talk through what you need, and your program gets built from there. If that sounds like what you’ve been looking for, apply for Movement Made for You.

Kim Hagle - Body Image Coach - Size Inclusive Fitness Specialist - Non Diet Nutritionist

Radiant Vitality – Kim Hagle

Body Positive Personal Trainer for Women Over 40. Located in Goderich, ON and serving clients online throughout North America

Check Out Our Latest Posts

  • What to Look for in a Personal Trainer as a Fitness Misfit

    What to Look for in a Personal Trainer as a Fitness Misfit

    What to look for in a personal trainer is a harder question than it should be, especially if you’ve ever felt like fitness wasn’t made for you. This guide is for the fitness misfit who wants to move more, feel stronger, and not get hurt doing it. We’ll walk through credentials, interview questions, and what…

  • Body Positive Fitness: A Guide for Women Who’ve Been Burned by Fitness Culture

    Body Positive Fitness: A Guide for Women Who’ve Been Burned by Fitness Culture

    Body positivity in fitness isn’t a trend, a marketing buzzword, or a softer way of selling you the same old fitness culture nonsense. It’s a completely different way of thinking about movement — one where your body doesn’t have to earn the right to exist in a gym, in workout clothes, or in a class…

  • I’m Scared to Go to the Gym Because of My Size

    I’m Scared to Go to the Gym Because of My Size

    If you’ve ever typed “I’m scared to go to the gym because of my size” into a search bar at midnight, this post is for you. I’m not going to tell you to push past your fear or give you a pep talk about confidence. I’m going to tell you something the fitness industry has…

Hey Gorgeous, I'm Kim (she/her)

I’m a body positive personal trainer for women over 40 who feel like “fitness misfits”.

It’s my mission to make the life changing benefits of movement available to ALL bodies, especially those who feel like they don’t “fit” in fitness spaces.

Begin and Build - 12 week beginner strength training program
Kim Hagle - Body Positive Personal Trainer for Women over 40

Thanks for Visiting the Radiant Vitality Blog

Kim Hagle  is a body positive personal trainer, body image coach and founder of Radiant Vitality Wellness.

She offers customized personal training, in person group fitness classes, online fitness programs and body image coaching services  in Goderich, ON  and virtually across North America.

Kim holds a BScN and is an ACE certified personal trainer.  She is also a size inclusive fitness specialist, and a certified health and life coach specializing in Body Image.  You can read more about Kim here.

Follow Radiant Vitality on Social

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Check Out Our Recent Posts